Judge George Mason is no stranger to criminal defense, but his latest assignment from the Court of Appeals makes him uneasy. The morally unquestionable crimes of a group of intoxicated fraternity brothers would horrify anyone, and the only argument the defense has is the use of evidence. But a lurking memory from Judge Mason's past leaves him with the age-old question, Who am I to judge? And now, in addition to his dilemma of conscience, he's receiving death threats in his supposedly secure email box. As Mason reaches back to his past, the source of the threats will reveal that we are all capable of sin and redemption.